Nformal Settlements’ Planning Theories and Policy-Making in Sub-saharan Africa – from ‘Site’ to ‘People’: A Critical Evaluation of Operations ‘Murambatsvina’ and ‘Garikai’ in Zimbabwe

Nformal Settlements’ Planning Theories and Policy-Making in Sub-saharan Africa – from ‘Site’ to ‘People’: A Critical Evaluation of Operations ‘Murambatsvina’ and ‘Garikai’ in Zimbabwe

Cyril Fegue

New York University Wagner, New York, USA.

Page: 
445-460
|
DOI: 
https://doi.org/10.2495/SDP-V2-N4-445-460
Received: 
N/A
|
Accepted: 
N/A
|
Published: 
14 December 2007
| Citation

OPEN ACCESS

Abstract: 

This article explores the theoretical debates on informal settlements and presents a critical overview of the related planning strategies. Operations Murambatsvina and Garikai have been the response of the Zimbabwean government to the rapid growth of uncontrolled and spontaneous settlements in major cities. This response sparked an avalanche of criticism throughout the international community. The article’s fundamental research question is to assess whether that response was structured in accordance with the ideal and recommended planning practices for informal settlements. Operations Murambatsvina and Garikai were gigantic failures; they were confi gured for humanitarian crisis. The proposal for remedial action in the long term is to take decentralization, good local governance, and community participation seriously. The article suggests that the revamp of the institutional and legal framework is hereby the conditio-sine-qua-non pathway.

Keywords: 

African context, civil society, community participation, decentralization, development administration, informal settlement planning, rapid urbanization, slum, squatter settlement, urban poor.

  References

[1] Burgel, G., Ville de désespérance? Le Logement, L’Etat et Les Pauvres dans Les Villes du TiersMonde, Revue Villes en Parallele, Laboratoire de Géographie Urbaine, CERCEAU, Vol. 8, 1984. 

[2] Obudho, R.A. & Mhlanga, C.C., Slum and Squatter Settlements in Sub-Saharan Africa, Toward a Planning Strategy, Praeger: New York, 1988.

[3] UN Habitat, Urbanization: Facts and Figures, Habitat Backgrounder, UN Habitat: Nairobi, available at http://ww2.unhabitat.org/istanbul+5/back11.doc, 2006.

[4] Rodwin, L. & Sanyal, B., Shelter, settlement, and development: an overview. Shelter, Settlement, and Development, ed. L. Rodwin, Allen & Uwin: Sydney, pp. 4–31, 1987.

[5] UNDP Human Development Report, Beyond Scarcity, Power, Poverty and the Global Water Crisis, United Nations Development Program (UNDP), 2006.

[6] Millennium Development Goals Report  , The United Nations, 2006.

[7] Burns, L.S. & Ferguson, B., Criteria for future shelter and settlement policies in developing countries. Shelter, Settlement, and Development, ed. L. Rodwin, Allen & Uwin: Sydney, pp. 282–303, 1987.

[8] Mbembe, A., On the Postcolony, University of California Press: Berkeley, CA, 2001.

[9] Bayart, J.F., L’Etat en Afrique, Editions Fayard: Paris, 1989.

[10] Gilroy, P., Postcolonial Melancholia, Columbia University Press: New York, 2005.

[11] Odhiambo, A., From African historiographies to an African philosophy of history. Africanizing Knowledge, African Studies Across Disciplines, eds T. Falola & C. Jennings, Transaction Publishers: New Brunswick, pp. 13–65, 2002.

[12] Asiama, S.O., Chieftaincy in a transient institution in urban Ghana. Sociologus,  31(2), pp. 122–140, 1981.

[13] Huchzermeyer, M., Proceedings of the Workshop on Informal Settlement Policy, Wits Club, University of Witwatersrand, 3 April 2003.

[14] Solzbacher, R.M., East African slum problem: a question of defi nition. Urban Growth in SubSaharan Africa, Nkanga Editions: Kampala, 1970.

[15] Mabogunje, A., Absorption of newcomers into African cities, UN Habitat Conference Background Paper, New York, Nr. 70/RPC/BP/12, 1970.

[16] Stren, R., Urban housing in Africa, the changing role of government policy. Housing Africa’s Urban Poor, eds P. Amis & P. Llyod, Manchester University Press: New York and Manchester, 1989.

[17] Stren, R., Urban Inequality and Housing Policy in Tanzania: The Problem of Squatting, University of California Institute of International Studies, Berkeley, Research Series, Vol. 24, 1975.

[18] Lewis, O., The Children of Sanchez, Random House: New York, 1961.

[19] Abrams, C., Man’s Struggle for Shelter in an Urbanizing World, The MIT Press Classic Series: Boston, 1966.

[20] Mangin, W., Latin American squatter settlements: a problem and a solution. Latin American Research Review, 2(3), pp. 65–98, 1967.

[21] Turner, J.F.C., Barriers and channels for housing development in modernizing countries. Journal of the American Institute of Planners, 33(3), pp. 167–181, 1967.

[22] World Bank, Sites and Services Project Surveys, The World Bank Group: Washington, DC, p. 3, 1974.

[23] Lewis, O., Livida: A Puerto Rican Family in the Culture of Poverty, Random House: New York, 1966.

[24] Sen, A.K., Development as Freedom, Alfred A. Knopf Publisher: New York, 1999.

[25] Bracking, S., Structural adjustment: why it wasn’t necessary and why it didn’t work. Review of African Political Economy, 26, pp. 207–226, 1999.

[26] Mosley, P., Attacking poverty and the post-Washington consensus. Journal of International Development, 13, pp. 307–313, 2001.

[27] Njoh, A.J., Urban Planning and Spatial Structures in Sub-Saharan Africa, Ashgate: Brookfi eld, 1999.

[28] Laquian, A.A., Basic Housing, Policies for Urban Sites, Services and Shelter in Developing Countries, International Development Research Center: Ottawa, 1983.

[29] Angel, S., Upgrading slum infrastructure: divergent objectives in search of consensus. The Third World Planning Review, 5(1), pp. 5–22, 1983.

[30] Mansuri, G. & Rao, V., Community-based and driven development: a critical review. The World Bank Research Observer, 19(1), pp. 1–39, 2004.

[31] Desai, V., Community Participation and Slum Housing: A Study of Bombay, SAGE Publications: New Delhi, 1995.

[32] Moser, C., Community Participation in Urban Project in the Third World, Progress in Planning, Vol. 32(2), 2001.

[33] Report of the Commission for Africa, In Our Common Interest, The Commission for Africa, 2005.

[34] The Zimbabwean  , 24–30 June 2005.

[35] Baumann, T., Bridging the fi nance gap in housing and infrastructure: the Zimbabwean case study, Homeless International, 2005.

[36] Zimbabwe Human Rights NGO Forum Report, Order Out of Chaos or Chaos out of Order: A Preliminary Report on Operation Murambatsvina, June 2005.

[37] Human Rights Watch, Clear the fi lth – mass evictions and demolitions in Zimbabwe, Human Rights Watch Briefi ng Paper, September 2005.

[38] UN Special Envoy on Human Settlement Issues in Zimbabwe, Report of the Fact-Finding Mission to Zimbabwe to Assess the Scope and Impact of Operation Murambatsvina, 22 July 2005.

[39] International Crisis Group Report, Zimbabwe’s Operation Murambtsvina: The Tipping Point?, International Crisis Group, 17 August 2005.

[40] The Herald Online  , Spearhead operation Garikai, council told, 15 July 2005.

[41] The Herald Online  , Garikai, solution to housing woes, 27 July 2005.

[42] UN Economic Commission for Africa, Economic Report on Africa: Tracking Performance and Progress, UNECA, 2004.