OPEN ACCESS
If official rhetoric is to be believed, the UK has been quick to respond to growing global demands for greater sustainability in the way we create the built environment. At the national level there has been a plethora of planning and related guidance stressing the importance of sustainable development, and the need for more sustainable housing has been a key tenet of these texts. The Building Research Establishment has had guidelines and a rating system for more sustainable ‘eco-home’ developments since the 1990s. The majority of housing development in the UK, however, outwardly and in plan form at least, seems little different to that built 25 years ago. So why should this be so? Why, when national government policy seems so driven by the sustainability enda and there are easily adopted national standards, should so little credence appear to be afforded them? This article begins to explore these tensions from the supply side of the equation and in particular in relation to the North East of England. It outlines the development of planning policy in the context of a growing sustainability agenda, the debates surrounding sustainable neighbourhoods and the pressure for new homes in the UK. The article then reviews an empirical research project which explores issues surrounding sustainable neighbourhood development with two types of housing provider. A group of volume house builders, used to providing the type of standardised products in developments that have faced much criticism in recent years and also bespoke providers, who are explicitly striving for more sustainable goals in their work, give their views. The research study covered a wide range of themes covering planning, construction and detailed design; this article focuses on the more ‘macro’ issues.
housing, neighbourhoods, standards.
[1] WorldCommissiononEnvironmentandDevelopment,OurCommonFuture,OxfordUniversity Press: Oxford, 1987.
[2] CEC (Commission of the European Communities), Green Paper on the Urban Environment, CEC: Brussels, 1990.
[3] CEC (Commission of the European Communities), Sustainable Cities Report, CEC: Brussels, 1990.
[4] HM Government, Sustainable Development – the UK Strategy; Cmnd 2426, HMSO: London, 1994.
[5] McGhie, C. & Girling, R., Local Attraction. The Design of New Housing in the Countryside, Council for the Protection of Rural England: London, 1995.
[6] Duany, A. & Plater-Zyberk, E., Towns and Town Making, Rizzoli: New York, 1991.
[7] Katz, P., The New Urbanism: Towards anArchitecture of Community, McGraw-Hill: NewYork, 1994.
[8] Calthorpe, P., Pedestrian pockets: new strategies for suburban growth. The Pedestrian Pocket Book:ANewSuburbanDesignStrategy,ed.D.Kelbaugh,PrincetonUniversityPress:Princeton, pp. 7–24, 1994.
[9] Calthorpe, P., The Next American Metropolis, Community and the American Dream, Princeton Architectural Press: New York, 1993.
[10] HM Government, A Better Quality of Life – A Strategy for Sustainable Development for the UK, HMSO: London, 1999.
[11] Elkins, P., The Big Picture, Social Housing and Sustainability, The Housing Corporation: London, 2000.
[12] Urban Task Force, Towards and Urban Renaissance, E & FN Spon: London, 1999.
[13] DETR, Our Towns and Cities: The Future – Delivering an Urban Renaissance, DETR: London, 2000.
[14] DETR, Planning Policy Guidance Note 3 Housing, DETR: London, 2000.
[15] DTLR & CABE, Better Places to Live: By Design – A Companion Guide to PPG3, DTLR & CABE: London, 2001.
[16] ODPM, Planning for Sustainable Development; Towards Better Practice, ODPM: London, 2003.
[17] ODPM, Sustainable Communities: Building for the Future, ODPM: London, 2003.
[18] ODPM, Planning Policy Statement 1: Delivering Sustainable Development, ODPM: London, p. 7, 2005.
[19] HMGovernment,SecuringtheFuture,DeliveringtheUKSustainableHousingStrategy,HMSO: London, 2005.
[20] ODPM,SustainableCommunities:HomesforAll.AFiveYearPlanfromtheOfficeoftheDeputy Prime Minister, ODPM: London, 2005.
[21] ODPM, Sustainable Communities: People, Places and Prosperity. A Five Year Plan from the Office of the Deputy Prime Minister, ODPM: London, 2005.
[22] Llewelyn-Davies, The Urban Design Compendium, English Partnerships/The Housing Corporation: London, 2000.
[23] DETR/CABE, By Design. Urban Design in the Planning System; Towards Better Practice, DETR: London, 2000.
[24] CABE, What Home Buyers Want: Attitudes and Decision Making Among Consumers, CABE: London, 2005.
[25] Hansen, L., Greenwich Millennium Village: a revolution in volume housing? Eco Design, 7(3), pp. 10–13, 1999.
[26] Dunster, B., BedZED – Beddington Zero – fossil fuel development. Sustainable Urban Design, An Environmental Approach, ed. R. Thomas, Spon Press: London, pp. 167–183, 2003.
[27] CABE, Housing Audit: Assessing the Design Quality of New Homes, London, the South East and the East of England, CABE: London, 2005.
[28] CABE, Housing Audit: Assessing the Design Quality of New Homes in the North East, North West and Yorkshire and Humber, CABE: London, 2005.
[29] Newman, P. & Kenworthy, J.R., Sustainable urban form: the big picture. Achieving Sustainable Urban Form, eds K.William, E. Burton & M. Jenks, E & FN Spon: London, pp. 109–120, 1989. [30] Sherlock, H., Cities and Good for Us, Paladin: London, 1991.
[31] McClaren, D., Compact or Dispersed? Dilution is no solution, Built Environment, 18(4), pp. 268–284, 1992.
[32] Jenks, M., Burton, E. & Williams, K. (eds), The Compact City a Sustainable Urban Form?, E & FN Spon: London, 1996.
[33] Kunstler, J.H., Home from Nowhere: Remaking Our Everyday World for the Twenty-First Century, Simon & Schuster: London, 1996.
[34] Williams, K., Burton, E. & Jenks, M. (eds), Achieving Sustainable Urban Form, Spon Press: London, 2000.
[35] Steemers, K., The paradox of the compact city, Architects Journal, 2 November, pp. 42–43, 2000.
[36] Barker, M., Solar ElectriCity Guide, Institut Cerda: Barcelona, 2001.
[37] Thomas, R., Building design. Sustainable Urban Design: an Environmental Approach, eds R. Thomas & M. Fordham, Spon Press: London, pp. 46–62, 2004.
[38] Breheny, M.J., Sustainable Development and Urban Form, Pion: London, 1992.
[39] Breheny, M.J., Urban compaction: feasible and acceptable. Cities, 14(4), pp. 209–217, 1997.
[40] Breheny, M.J., Gurney, A. & Strike, J., The compact city and the need to travel: the implementation of UK planning policy guidance. The Compact City: A Sustainable Urban Form?, eds M. Jenks, K. Williams & E. Wilson, E & FN Spon: London, pp. 13–35, 1996.
[41] Frey, H. Designing the City: Towards a More Sustainable Urban Form, Spon Press: London, 1999.
[42] Horland, E. & Norland, I.T., Three challenges for the compact city as a sustainable urban from:
households consumption of energy and transport in eight residential areas in the Greater Oslo Region. Urban Studies, 42(12), pp. 2145–2166, 2005.
[43] Morrow-Jones, E.G.I., & Roe, B., Consumer preferences for neotraditional neighborhood characteristics. Housing Policy Debate, 15(1), pp. 171–202, 2004.
[44] MulhollandResearchAssociatesLtd,TownsorLeafierEnvironments?ASurveyofFamilyHome Buying Choices – Summary of Main Findings, House Builders Federation: London, 1995.
[45] Forest, R., Kennet, T. & Leather, P., Home Owners on New Estates in the 1990s, Policy Press: Bristol, 1997.
[46] Hooper,A.,Dunmore,K.&Hughes,M.,HomeAlone,Volumes1and2,NationalHouseBuilding Council: Amersham, 1998.
[47] Senior, M.L., Webster, C.J. & Blank, N.E., Residential preferences versus sustainable cities; quantitative and qualitative evince form a survey of relocating owner-occupiers. Town Planning Review, 75(3), pp. 337–357, 2004.
[48] Andrews,C.L.,Reardon-Smith,W.&Townshend,M.,ButWillWeWanttoLiveThere?Planning for People and Neighbourhoods in 2020, Women and Housing: Didcot, 2004.
[49] House Builders Federation, Places for People: Comments for the Proposed Urban White Paper, HBF: London, 2000.
[50] Tiesdell, S. & Adams, T., Design matters: major house builders and the design challenge of brownfield development contexts. Journal of Urban Design, 9(1), pp. 23–45, 2004.
[51] Farooki, I., Denser living. Urban Environment Today, October 11, pp. 12–13, 2001.
[52] Cooper,J.,Ryley,T.&Smyth,A.,Theinteractionbetweenconsumerresponseandurbandesign: empirical results from Belfast. Environment and Planning A, 33(3), pp. 1265–1278, 2001.
[53] Mulholland Research and Consulting, Perceptions of Privacy & Density in Housing, Design for Homes Popular Housing Research: London, 2003.
[54] Barker, E., Review of Housing Supply – Delivering Stability: Securing Our Future Needs, Final Report – Recommendations, ODPM: London, 2004.
[55] Champion, A., Migration between Metropolitan and Non-Metropolitan Areas in Britain, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Department of Geography: Newcastle upon Tyne, 1996.
[56] Champion, A., Atkins, D., Coombes, M. & Fotheringham, S., Urban Exodus: A Report for the CPRE, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Department of Geography: Newcastle upon Tyne, 1998.
[57] David Cumberland Housing Regeneration Ltd., North East Housing Strategy, Government Office for the North East: Newcastle upon Tyne, 2003.
[58] Townshend, T.G., From inner city to inner suburb. Housing Studies, 21(4), pp. 501–521, 2006. [59] Ball, M., Markets and the structure of the housebuilding industry: an international perspective. Urban Studies, 40(5), pp. 897–916, 2003.
[60] CPRE, LocalAttraction: The Design of New Housing in the Countryside, CPRE: London, 1995.
[61] English Partnerships, Time for Design2, Good Practice in Building, Landscape and Urban Design, English Partnerships: London, 1998.
[62] Carmona, M., Housing Design Quality, through Policy, Guidance and Review, Spon Press: London.
[63] Barton, H. (ed.), Sustainable Communities, the Potential for Eco-Neighbourhoods, Earthscan: London, 2003.
[64] Association of Chief Police Officers Crime Prevention Initiatives Ltd., Secured by Design – New Homes, ACPO-CPI Ltd: London, 2004.
[65] BRE, Eco-Homes – The Environmental Rating for Homes, Building Research Establishment: Watford, 2003.
[66] Guest, P., Fresh BREEAM. Building, 25(39), pp. 58–59, 1991.
[67] Rao, S., Yates, A., Brownhill, D. & Howard, N., EcoHomes: The Environmental Rating for Homes, Building Research Establishment: Watford, 2000.
[68] Priaulx, M, Building for a future. EcoHomes, Spring, pp. 11–19, 2004.
[69] BRE Trust & Cyril Sweett, Putting a Price on Sustainability, BRE: Watford, 2005.