National Translation of the EU Landfill Directives—Will Landfills Become Sustainable?

National Translation of the EU Landfill Directives—Will Landfills Become Sustainable?

M. Van Praagh K.M. Persson 

Department of Water Resources Engineering, Lund University, Sweden

Page: 
46-60
|
DOI: 
https://doi.org/10.2495/SDP-V1-N1-46-60
Received: 
N/A
|
Accepted: 
N/A
|
Published: 
3 March 2006
| Citation

OPEN ACCESS

Abstract: 

The key issues of the EU Landfill Directives (1999/31/EC and 2003/33/EC) are elucidated with respect to the directives’ objectives towards sustainable waste management. In countries such as Sweden the national translation of the directives’ requirements will lead to dryer landfills with relatively more municipal solid waste (MSW) incineration residues. Numerous landfills have been closed before the initially envisaged date. They will not be subject to the advanced closing procedure for landfills according to the translation of the EU directives. Together with former unengineered dumps, these landfills will outnumber the compliant landfills by far. The former are neither subject to the Swedish national translation of the Landfill Directives nor to any other EU or national legislation. Often lacking active and even passive barrier systems, the emission potential of these landfills seems to be able to overshadow that of the reduced number of remaining EU directive-compliant landfills. These landfills will eventually be regarded as contaminated areas. In countries such as Sweden a substitution of MSW landfills by incineration facilities will result in a more rapid and likely increased release of carbon dioxide emissions (among other air pollutants) per tonne of produced waste. Thus, a comparative assessment of the overall impact of waste management options on different timescales for emissions should be done on a countryby- country basis to assess sustainability of the translation of the Landfill Directives. The physical–chemical and microbiological properties of the resulting storage conditions governing the landfills’ emission potentials are unknown to a great extent. A prolonged risk of relevant emissions has to be taken into account for compliant landfills due to possible moisture scarcity and subsequent slower degradation rates. On the one hand, leaching of degradation products could be extended, albeit in reduced concentrations. On the other hand, longer contact time with water can enhance leaching of, for example, hydrophilic substances. Concentration and/or mass peaks might be postponed compared to earlier, ‘wetter’ landfilling with a higher content of easily degradable organic waste. Without addressing and answering these uncertainties, it remains doubtful it the national translation of the Landfill Directives will lead to sustainable waste management in the long run.

Keywords: 

landfill, legislation, long-term emissions, storage conditions, sustainable waste management.

  References

[1] Smith, A., Brown, K., Ogilvie, S., Rushton, K. & Bates, J., Waste Management Options and Climate Change, Final report to the European Commission, Final Report ED21158R4.1, Office for Official Publications of the European Communities: Luxembourg, 2001.

[2] Anonymous, Report for DGXI, Options to Reduce Methane Emissions (Final Report), AEAT3773, Issue 3, 1998.

[3] Eurostat, Treatment of Municipal Waste. Eurostat/New Cronos, http://europa.eu.int/

[4] Estrela, T., Marcuello, C. & Iglesias, A., Water Resources Problems in Southern Europe—An Overview Report, Topic Report No. 15/1996, 1996.

[5] Austrian EPA, Federal Statistic on Contaminated Areas, http://www.umweltbundesamt.at/umwelt/altlasten_start/statistik/, 2003.

[6] Perz, K., Waste Generation, Treatment and Recovery and Disposal in Austria (Aufkommen, Verwertung und Behandlung von Abfällen in Österreich, Materialien zum BundesAbfallwirtschaftsplan 2001, in German), Federal Environmental Agency-Umweltbundesamt GmbH, Monographien Band 138, Klagenfurt, Austria, 2001.

[7] Danish Environmental Ministry, Waste Statistics 2002 (Affaldsstatistik 2002, in Danish), Orientering fra Miljøstyrelsen, Miljøministeriet, http://www.mst.dk, 2003.

[8] German EM, Contaminated sites—situation and mitigation procedures, http://www.bmu.de/, German Environmental Ministry, 2003.

[9] German EM, Provisions on cross-border waste disposal into the 10 accession countries after ratification of accession treaties, http://www.bmu.de/de/, German Environmental Ministry, 2003.

[10] Hjelmar, O., Johannessen, L.M., Knox, K., Ehrig, H.-J., Flyvbjerg, J., Winther, P. & Christensen, T.H., Management and Composition of Leachate from Landfills, Final Report for the Commission of the European Communities, DGXI A.4, Waste 92, VKI: Hørsholm, Denmark, 1994.

[11] RVF, Waste Management in Sweden 2003, The Swedish Association of Waste Management (RVF), http://www.rvf.se, 2003.

[12] Swedish EPA, Waste Management/Household Waste (Avfallsteknik/hushållsavfall, in Swedish), Swedish Environmental Protection Agency, http://www.naturvardsverket.se, 2003.

[13] SCB, National Economic Data, Swedish Statistical Database, http://www.scb.se, 2003.

[14] Brandt, M., Eklund, A. & Westman, Y., Snow in Sweden, Snow Depth and Water Content in Snow (in Swedish), Fakta nr. 2, Swedish Meteorological Institute (SMHI): Stockholm, Sweden, 1999.

[15] RVF, Waste Management Sites with Landfilling, Statistics 2002 (‘Avfallsanläggningar med deponering, statistic 2002’, in Swedish), RVF report 203:8, The Swedish Association of Waste Management (RVF), ISSN 1103-4092, 2003; RVF, Swedish Waste Management 2003, 2004, 2005, The Swedish Association of Waste Management (RVF), www.rvf.se.

[16] SNV, Governmental Request—Map of Municipal Waste Management Plans (Regeringsupp drag—kartläggning av hur kommunerna planerar att omhänderta sitt avfall, in Swedish), Swedish Environmental Protection Agency: Stockholm, 2000.

[17] Öman, C., Malmberg, M. & Wolf-Watz, C., Manual for Characterization of Leachate (Handbok för lakvattenbedömning, in Swedish), RVF report 00:7, IVL, Swedish Environmental Institute: Stockholm, 2000.

[18] Kruempelbeck, I. & Ehrig, H.-J., Long-term behaviour of municipal solid waste landfills in Germany, Sardinia 99, Proc. of the Seventh International Landfill Symposium, CISA, Cagliari, Italy, I, pp. 27–36, 1999.

[19] SNV, Evaluation of the Consequences of the Landfill Directive’s Implementation (Utvärdering av genomförandet av deponeringsdirektivet, in Swedish), Dnr NV 641-592-02, Swedish Environmental Protection Agency: Stockholm, 2003.

[20] Maurice, C. & Lagerkvist, A., LFG emission measurements in cold climate conditions: seasonal variations and methane emissions mitigation. Cold Regions Science and Technology, 36, pp. 37–46, 2003.

[21] Roman, E. & Haarstad, K., North-south gradient in leachate quality in Norway, Sardinia 2003, Proc. of the Ninth International Landfill Symposium. CISA, Cagliari, Italy, 2003.

[22] SNV, Follow Up of Landfill Prohibit (‘Uppföljning av deponeringsförbud’, in Swedish), Report Nr. 5383, Swedish Environmental Protection Agency: Stockholm, 2004.

[23] Sundberg, J., Capacity for Combustible and Organic Waste (‘Kapacitet för omhändertagande av brännbart och organiskt avfall’, in Swedish), RVF rapport 1103-4092; 02:02, The Swedish Association of Waste Management (RVF): Malmö, 2002.

[24] Fällmann, A.-M., Larsson, L., Myrhede, E. & Sundberg, J., Leachate from Special Waste, Metal Waste and Sorting Residues (‘Lakvatten från specialavfall, metal- och restavfall (MRA) och sorteringsrester’, in Swedish), Report Nr. 1 2000, The Swedish Association of Waste Management (RVF): Malmö, 1999.

[25] van Praagh, M. & Persson, K.M., Estimating and predicting actual landfill emissions by flux measurements in different scales—theory and practice, manuscript, 2004.

[26] USA EPA, Bioreactors, What is a Bioreactor Landfill, US Environmental Protection Agency. http://www.epa.gov/epaoswer/non-hw/muncpl/landfill/bioreactors.htm, 2003.

[27] EU, Decision No. 1600/2002/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 22 July 2002 laying down the Sixth Community Environment Action Programme, OJ L 242/1, 2002.

[28] Sundqvist, J.O., Sundberg, J., Granath, J., Olofsson, M. & Ljunggren Söderman, M., Synthesis of system analyses in waste management—environmental aspects (in Swedish), IVL, Stockholm Environmental Institute, 2001.

[29] Kjeldsen, P. & Christophersen, M., Composition of leachate from old landfills in Denmark, Sardinia 99, Proc. of the Seventh International Landfill Symposium, CISA, Cagliari, Italy, II, pp. 105–112, 1999.

[30] Prokop, G., Schaman, M. & Edelgaard, I., Management of Contaminated Sites in Western Europe, Topic Report No. 13/1999, European Environmental Agency: Copenhagen, 2000.