© 2024 The authors. This article is published by IIETA and is licensed under the CC BY 4.0 license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
OPEN ACCESS
This article focuses on the management development plan for the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area, Solok Selatan Regency, Indonesia. The research methods used in this study are the desk study method, participatory qualitative methods through focus group discussions (FGD), and direct observation methods at the research location. The results of this study illustrate several points, namely: governance analysis, analysis of the position of tourist areas in the RTRW document, Analysis of Zoning System, Accessibility Analysis, Internal Travel Pattern Analysis, Parking Management Analysis, Circulation Analysis, Pedestrian Analysis and Activity Actor Analysis and Facilities in the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area. The recommendation from this study is that the policy for managing the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area must involve active participation from the community, private sector, central, regional, and Nagari governments, which are very determining factors in encouraging and moving tourism in the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area to become a leading tourist destination, thereby providing benefits, which is bigger both from a historical, cultural and economic perspective.
tourism policy, tourism development, Indonesia
Analysis from the World Travel and Tourism Council (WTC) and World Bank in 2016 showed that the tourism sector in Indonesia contributed 10% of the Gross Domestic Product (GDP), ranking 4th as a contributor to national foreign exchange at 9.3% with the highest growth at 13% and marketing costs are only 2% of foreign exchange projections and can contribute 9.8 jobs with 30% growth in 5 years, so the tourism sector is considered to be the sector with the most potential in the future [1].
In the last sixty years, tourism has continued to experience diversification and expansion, becoming one of the most significant and fastest-growing economic sectors to achieve sustainable development [2-4]. In the context of this growth, improving the competitive position of destinations is a significant factor to consider when planning the tourism sector in a sustainable manner [5].
Over the last two decades, tourism has become an essential aspect of regional development. In Indonesia, the tourism sector has experienced significant growth. It has become a vital economic factor and an alternative source of income from the non-oil and gas sector [6, 7]. Many regions in Indonesia consistently prioritize tourism as the spearhead of community economic development, using it as a means to optimize local potential and wealth. Tourism provides opportunities for local communities to utilize their land in various capacities, including the redefinition and restructuring of cultural identity and historical legitimacy [7, 8].
Currently, in Indonesia, tourist travel trends are marked by new travel motivations and patterns carried out by tourists, especially in the market segment of mature and experienced tourists who are educated and experienced. High education, deep concern for environmental conservation issues, and empowerment of local communities and culture [9, 10].
Travel activities carried out by a person or group of people by visiting certain places for recreation, personal development, or studying the unique attractions of the places visited for a short period are known as tourism. This tourist activity cannot be separated from transportation because of the action of visiting certain areas, so transportation is an essential element in a tourist activity. Tourism is only carried out briefly, so supporting facilities are needed to realize these activities. Multiple facilities and services provided by the community, entrepreneurs, Government, and Regional Government, known as Tourism (Law No. 10 of 2009 concerning Tourism, 2009), support various tourism activities. Management like this is measured regularly, and they can improve weaknesses and increase the strengths of each destination while facing threats and taking advantage of opportunities that exist in the tourism sector at any time [11-15].
Tourism policy management involves various aspects, including planning, developing, and implementing strategies to promote and maintain the tourism sector [16]. These policies usually include tourist destination development, increasing accessibility, infrastructure development, and human resource management in the tourism industry [17, 18]. Furthermore, policy directions in tourism development include tourist attractions, which include natural attractions, cultural tourism, artificial tourism, or events in tourist destination areas [19-21]. The development of tourism potential in an area depends on various factors, including location, accessibility, market demand, proximity to other popular tourist destinations, marketing, the presence of local tourism businesses, and tourism infrastructure [22].
Natural conditions and cultural uniqueness are the main potential for developing tourism in Solok Selatan Regency. One of the main tourist destinations in Solok Selatan Regency is the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area. As a leading tourist destination, the SRG Tourism Area must be managed well so that all stakeholders, including the community, business actors, and government, receive proportional benefits. From the community side, there will be an increase in economic and social welfare. Meanwhile, from the business actor's side, they get legal certainty to invest and do profitable and sustainable business. From the government's side, it will obtain potential regional revenue, which will be used to increase development and improve services to the community. Apart from that, with a good management policy in the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area, it must also pay attention to environmental sustainability from an ecological and socio-cultural perspective. The SRG area has a Rumah Gadang, which is quite old and has unique characteristics. Each Rumah Gadang is still maintained today. This traditional Rumah Gadang is thought to have existed since 1794 when Rumah Gadang was inherited by the 5th traditional stakeholder [23].
Based on data from the Indonesian National Tourism Development Master Plan (RIPPARNAS), the position of West Sumatra Province is included in 2 National Tourism Destinations (DPN), namely the Mentawai-Siberut DPN and its surroundings and the Padang-Bukittinggi DPN and its surroundings. DPN Padang-Bukittingi and its environs have 7 National Tourism Development Areas (KPPN), namely:
a) KPPN Padang and surrounding areas
b) KPPN Bukittinggi and surrounding areas
c) KPPN Singkarak and surrounding areas
d) KPPN Batusangkar and surrounding areas
e) KPPN Sawahlunto and surrounding areas
f) KPPN Maninjau and surrounding areas
g) KPPN Pesisir Selatan and surrounding areas
DPN Padang-Bukittingi and its surroundings have 2 National Tourism Strategic Areas (KSPN), namely Bukittingi and Maninjau. Based on this area, Solok Selatan Regency, especially the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area, is included in the Padang-Bukittinggi DPN area and its surroundings and is located in the Singkarak National Tourism Strategic Area (KSPN) and its environs; besides that, Solok Selatan Regency is also.
Based on Regional Regulation Number 3 of 2014, West Sumatra Province concerning the West Sumatra Tourism Development Master Plan (RIPAR) for 2014-2025, Solok Selatan Regency is included in the Main Provincial Tourism Area (KUPP) II with its centre being Tanah Datar Regency which consists of the Provincial Tourism Strategic Area (KSPP) Padang Panjang and Solok Regency, as well as the Provincial Tourism Potential Area (KPPP) Solok City and KPPP Solok Selatan. KPPP regional development is focused on marketing and industrial development without neglecting institutional and destination development. The provincial government of Solok Selatan Regency must respond to this condition by preparing strategies and steps to accelerate tourism development in this region.
The response regarding the National and Provincial tourism hierarchy was carried out by the Solok Selatan Regency Government by preparing a Regional Tourism Development Master Plan for the Solok Selatan Regency. Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area was designated the Tourism Development Area (KPP) 2 Muara Labuah. Muara Labuh KPP is prepared as an area for tourism activities, which is predicted to develop with the highest tourism concentration in the Solok Selatan Regency. Muara Labuh KPP covers three sub-districts: Sungai Pagu District, Koto Parik Gadang Diateh District, and Pauh Duo District. This KPP designated Muara Labuh City as a primary service centre. This KPP focuses on developing the tourism theme: "Cultural Tourism of the Traditional Village of Saribu Rumah Gadang supported by Nature Tourism, with superior attractions: Traditional Village of Saribu Rumah Gadang Koto Baru, King Balun Palace, King's Palace Plus "Raja Alam Surambi Sungai Pagu," Tubing Ducati (Ducati Body Rafting) and Hot Water Boom (HWB) Sapan Maluluang. The appointment as KPP will, of course, have consequences, namely that the regional government must pay more attention to this area to make further arrangements regarding the management of site use to improve the local economy and the welfare of the surrounding community and control tourism growth.
As part of tourism development, the regional development stages are the basis for formulating further spatial plans. Regionalization is a method aimed at determining the boundaries of spatial homogeneity, especially regarding attractions, amenities, and accessibility. Specifically, the division of KSPK for Solok Selatan Regency is based on several conditions, including:
Meanwhile, based on the data found, the type of attraction offered at the tourism destination in the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area is cultural tourism. The Pagu River area is a traditional Minangkabau residential area that consists of traditional Minangkabau buildings such as Rumah Gadang, ancient mosques, and tombs. Administratively, the Sungai Pagu area is located in Sungai Pagu District, which consists of 4 Nagari (village level), namely:
The existence of this area has caused Solok Selatan Regency to be called the district with "1000 Rumah Gadang," which can be seen in Table 1 below.
Table 1. Attraction locations of the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area
No |
BCB/Site Name |
Address |
|
Subdistrict |
Nagari |
||
1 |
Nagari Koto Baru Traditional Hall |
Sungai Pagu |
Koto Baru |
2 |
Batu Mosque (Great Mosque of Koto Baru) |
Sungai Pagu |
Koto Baru |
3 |
Tower Surau |
Sungai Pagu |
Koto Baru |
4 |
Surau Datuak St. Nan Kodo |
Sungai Pagu |
Koto Baru |
5 |
Maulana Sheikh Mustafa’s grave |
Sungai Pagu |
Koto Baru |
6 |
Medan Nan Bapaneh Arts Stage |
Sungai Pagu |
Koto Baru |
7 |
Viewing Tower |
Sungai Pagu |
Koto Baru |
Meanwhile, access as one of the pillars of the tourist destination in the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area, including airports, ports, terminals, train stations, tourism information, road quality, and telecommunications facilities, must be managed well. To be able to travel to the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area, several accesses can be used, as can be seen in Table 2 below:
Table 2. Access to tourism in the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area
No |
Access Type |
Access Name |
Address |
1 |
Airport |
BIM |
160 Km from Solok Selatan |
2 |
Harbor |
Gulf Harbor Bayur |
160 Km from Solok Selatan |
3 |
Bus station |
Padang Aro |
Muaro Pumpkin |
4 |
Tourism Information |
Pertamina |
Pegu River |
5 |
Road Quality |
Public Health Center Muaro Pumpkin |
Murao Labuah |
6 |
Telecommunication |
Pagu River Police |
Pagu River |
Based on these considerations, this paper focuses on management concepts that can later become the basis for designing government policies/regulations to accelerate the optimal development of the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area. For this reason, a management document for the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area is needed by considering several aspects, namely in terms of planning, organization, direction, and supervision, so it is better, professional, and profitable for all stakeholders. This research aims to design a management plan for the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area, which focuses on identifying and designing a management strategy for the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area and second, designing the concept of community participation in managing the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area in Solok Selatan Regency, Indonesia.
The Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area is an area that has a unique heritage in the form of many long rumah gadang that is not found in other regions of Minangkabau and is integrated with cultural attractions and local wisdom. The unique culture that has developed in this area is the art of batombe, which is not found in other areas in West Sumatra, so it requires a study of good management policies following the conditions of the local community.
Tourism management with a destination governance approach to the implementation level can be done through cooperation with the Ministry of Tourism of the Republic of Indonesia. The Solok Selatan Regency Government can utilize this draft tourism development policy to prepare more detailed governance following the directions of the Regional Tourism Development Master Plan (RIPPARDA). Meanwhile, the capacity-building strategy is aimed at managers at the tourist attractions, tourist attraction management, and Tourism Forum, where capacity-building in the planning aspect is significant, especially in planning programs and setting clear goals and stages of implementation. Another important thing that is no less important is the monitoring program. In many destinations in Indonesia, the monitoring program is always the weakest thing because monitoring is usually not planned from the start. At the current stage where tourism in Solok Selatan Regency is improving, it is essential to determine indicators of success since 2017 for every five years and every year. Then, a periodic monitoring framework for the programs that have been carried out will be created.
1) Tourism management concept
Tourism management is carried out to form management patterns that are applied to tourism areas. The management concept must be a step in resolving managerial problems at tourist attractions. The management concept is prepared based on existing management conditions and the needs of all parties who play a role in the tourist attraction development process [24]—structuring and organizing tourism as an economic sector where leaders must formulate available resources and manage them to be efficient and appropriate for all parties involved.
A tourism destination is a physical space with or without administrative and analytical boundaries where visitors can spend the night. A tourist destination is a collection of long experiences in tourism products, services, and activities. Destination Management is the coordinated management of all elements of a tourism destination, including attractions, facilities, access, marketing, and costs. The responsibility and sustainability of tourism destination management must incorporate processes that effectively and harmoniously direct interactions between visiting tourists, the industry offering services, the host community, and the environment in general. The long-term goal of destination management is Smart Destination, which is based on 5 pillars: Governance, Innovation, Technology, Accessibility, and Sustainability.
2) Tourism area development concept
Planning is organizing the future to achieve specific goals [25]. According to Paturusi [26], a plan has the following requirements:
Paturusi [26] added that there are two forms of planning orientation, namely, planning based on existing trends (trend-oriented planning), which is a plan to achieve goals and objectives in the future based on existing and developing considerations and practices at this time, then planning based on target considerations (target-oriented planning) is a plan in which the goals and objectives to be achieved in the future is the determining factor.
According to Yoeti [27], the essential components of tourism development in the planning process are tourist attractions and activities, accommodation facilities and services, other tourist facilities and services, transportation facilities and services, other infrastructure, and institutional elements. The tourism planning process looks at the environment (physical, economic, social, political) as interrelated components and dependent on one another [26]. Based on several expert opinions, tourism planning is a process of making decisions related to the future of a tourist destination or tourist attraction, which is a dynamic process of determining goals, systematically considering various alternative actions to achieve goals, implementation of selected alternatives, and evaluation.
3) Strategy and development of tourist attractions
UNWTO [28] suggests that there are 4 (four) components that a tourist attraction must have, namely: (1) attractions, such as attractive nature, charming regional culture, and performing arts; (2) accessibility (accessibilities), such as local transportation and terminals; (3) amenities or facilities such as the availability of accommodation, restaurants and travel agents; (4) ancillary services, namely tourism organizations needed to serve tourists such as destination marketing management organizations, conventional and visitor bureaus. In developing tourism, it is necessary to pay attention to these aspects, as stated by Yoeti [27], namely:
4) Sustainable tourism development
UNWTO [28] defines sustainable tourism development as development that meets the needs of tourists today and protects and encourages opportunities for the future. Aim at the management of all resources in such a way that economic, social, and aesthetic needs can be met and maintain cultural integrity, essential ecological processes, biodiversity, and life support systems. Sustainable tourism products are operated in harmony with the local environment, society, and culture to become permanent beneficiaries and not victims of tourism development.
However, many destinations face challenges in preserving environmental quality, affecting visitor satisfaction and resulting in smaller revenues from tourism-related activities [29]. Despite its positive impacts, tourism has contributed to environmental degradation, adverse social and cultural effects, and habitat fragmentation [29, 30].
The natural environment strongly influences tourism development, but tourism also hurts the environment, as shown by the lack of appropriate sustainable development strategies [31-34]. Sustainable tourism is also related to reducing the negative impact of tourism activities on the environment, society, and economy so that ecological sustainability, economic viability, and social equality can be achieved [34, 35].
Sustainable tourism development planning is carried out by managing tourism resources (TourismResources) spread throughout the country. Before a plan is implemented for sustainable tourism development, it is necessary first to approach local traditional leaders [27], who must explain the project's benefits and advantages to the local population by socializing. Strategic Planning for Sustainable Tourism Development provides the following framework [27]:
This research uses the research and development method (Research and Development/R & D) and qualitative data analysis. The method used in this research uses 3 (three) approach methods:
To obtain primary data in this study, researchers determine people or informants considered to know and can be trusted to be critical informants relevant to the research topic. This is done by assuming that the informants selected are responsible, have authority, and play an active role in formulating and implementing policies for managing the Saribu Rumah Gadang tourism area. The following Table 3 showa a list of informants for this research:
Table 3. Data of informant
No. |
Informant Institution |
|
Regency Government of Solok Selatan |
|
Tourism Agency of Solok Selatan |
|
Regency Development Planning Agency of Solok Selatan |
|
Public Works Agency of Solok Selatan |
|
Community and Village Empowerment Agency of Solok Selatan |
|
Non-Govermental Organization |
|
Tourism Actors and Activists |
|
Customary Leaders of Solok Selatan |
|
Tourism Business Actors |
|
Owner of Rumah Gadang |
|
Community Tourism Group |
|
Tourism Experts and Specialists |
After the research data is collected, the next step is categorizing or grouping data simultaneously with data reduction. The validity of the collected data is done using triangulation techniques.
Solok Selatan Regency has high socio-cultural potential and prospects of being developed as a tourist attraction. Solok Selatan Regency is also famous for the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area. Entering the Koto Baru area in the Sungai Pagu Sub District, we will find many Rumah Gadang buildings of various models. The Saribu Rumah Gadang Alam Surambi Sungai Pagu area proves that Solok Selatan has long, long historical roots in Minangkabau history. In this district, a kingdom called the Sungai Pagu Kingdom was established. Even though there is no written evidence regarding the periodization of the kingdom's founding, many cultural values exist, including material remains known as the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area. In this area, you can find many traditional Minangkabau houses that still survive today, as seen in Figure 1 below:
Figure 1. Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area
The Koto Baru strategic area is an area that has a large number of Rumah Gadang heritage and relatively close distances. Besides the Rumah Gadang, there is the Surau Menara site and the Grand Mosque of Koto Baru. This area by Dr. Meutia Hatta is nicknamed the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area and Traditional Village. This area was developed as a cultural tourism area. This area won the Indonesian Pesona Award (API) in 2017, so it is hoped that it will be able to increase the volume of tourist visits. The main attractions of the Saribu Rumah Gadang area include:
a) Saribu Rumah Gadang Traditional Village
b) Surau Menara & Koto Baru Grand Mosque
c) Ducati Touring Nature Tour (Ducati Body Rafting)
Apart from that, Solok Selatan Regency has traditional arts and culture that are still well preserved, including:
a) Nagari traditional ceremony
b) Minang traditional wedding ceremony
c) Traditional children's play art
d) The art of responding to rhymes
e) Randai (circular) art, an artistic tradition combining music, singing, dance, drama, and silat performances, is usually performed at traditional ceremonies and festivals.
f) Silat arts with 26 silat gyms
g) Tampuruang dance art
h) Pencak silat martial arts ampek steps
i) Barongsai martial arts
j) Ritual of going down to the rice fields (Nandabiah Kabau Nan Gadang)
k) Festival of 1000 Rumah Gadang
l) Sasurambi Regional Festival (FSS)
The Solok Selatan Regency RTRW documents divide 4 tourism designated areas, namely cultural, natural, historical, and artificial tourism. The Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area is categorized as a Cultural Tourism Designated. For cultural tourism, Solok Selatan Regency has potential in the form of a collection of Rumah Gadang in four areas spread across Nagari Pasir Talang, Koto Baru in Sungai Pagu District, and in Nagari Ranah Pantai Cermin and Abai in Sangir Batanghari District. This collection of Rumah Gadang nearby has the potential to be used as a cultural tourism area because it displays the uniqueness of typical Minangkabau settlements. The development of this area is combined with the preservation of traditional arts and living traditions that thrive in society. Many arts and traditions are growing, such as marriage alek, maraak bungo lamang alek, batombe, pencak silat, and gandang sarunai. Apart from enjoying distinct Minangkabau settlements, tourists can also enjoy the arts and traditions that thrive among the people of Solok Selatan Regency. The areas developed for cultural tourism in Solok Selatan Regency can be seen in the following Table 4:
Table 4. Allocation of cultural tourism areas
No. |
Tourist Area |
Object Tourism and Attractions Culture Supporter |
Location |
1. |
Nagari Saribu area Rumah Gadang Koto Baru |
Rumah Gadang, Koto Baru Grand Mosque, Surau Menara, Randai, Silek luncu, and Gandang Sarunai |
New Nagari Koto Sungai Pagu District |
2. |
Natural Kingdom Central Area Surambi Pagu River in Pasir Talang |
Rumah Gadang, Ustanorajo Nan Barampek, Less Aso Anampuluah Mosque, Randai, Silek luncu, and Gandang Sarunai |
Nagari Pasia Talang, Pasia Talang Timur, and Pasir Talang Barat in Sungai Pagu District |
3. |
Gadang Panjang area in Abai |
Rumah Gadang Panjang, Rumah Gadang 21 rooms, art Batombe, and Alek's marriage. |
Nagari Abai District Sangir Batanghari |
4. |
Gadang area in the Cermin Beach area |
Rumah Gadang Panjang, Alek marriage and Mangosteen center |
Nagari Ranah Cermin Beach Subdistrict Sangir Batanghari |
Source: Solok Selatan Regency RTRW Document 2011-2031
Saribu Rumah Gadang Nagari Koto Baru, Sungai Pagu, Solok Selatan functions as a cultural heritage area; the management of the WRS Area must, of course, be based on the provisions for Cultural Heritage management as regulated in Law No. 11 of 2010 concerning Cultural Heritage. Several zoning systems are possible in cultural heritage areas. The zoning system regulates the function of space in Cultural Heritage, both vertically and horizontally. Zoning is based on protection, balance, sustainability, coordination, and community empowerment. Vertical zoning arrangements can be made for the natural environment above the Cultural Heritage on land. The Zoning System consists of:
The zoning determination in the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area is carried out with a radius of 100 (one hundred meters) from the outer boundary of the core zone. This is more clearly explained in the following map (Figure 2):
Figure 2. Zoning system map of the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area
The division of the zoning system is based on applicable laws regarding cultural heritage and tribal systems in the core area. The following is an explanation based on the zoning of the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area as follows:
5.1 Analysis of accessibility policy design for Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area
Based on the scope of the Traffic Impact Analysis document results, the traffic performance of the Saribu Rumah Gadang area is estimated to include roads and intersections. The following is the coverage of the study area for the Traffic Impact Analysis Results Document for the Nagari Saribu Rumah Gadang Area in the Solok Selatan Regency.
Figure 3. Coverage of sections and intersections in the Saribu Rumah Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area
The study area covers 4 intersections: Simpang Empat in the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area, Simpang Tiga in Nan Limo Village, Simpang Tiga in front of RSUD, and Simpang Tiga in front of SMA 4 (Figure 3). Meanwhile, the road section consists of 5 (five) segments. National strategic road segment Jl. Raya Koto Baru, the other four segments are environmental roads within the Nagari Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area. A traffic zone is a geographic unit used to analyze traffic movements. The division of zones in the study area is determined by considering the zones inside (internal) and outside (external) the study area. The transportation model for this study area is divided into 7 (seven) zone areas. The division of zones is carried out to make it easier to classify vehicles based on the origin and destination of travel, which is very important as input data in modelling the road network system. The details of the zone division are shown in the following Table 5:
Table 5. Distribution of traffic zones
No. |
Zone |
Coverage Area |
Information |
1 |
Zone 1 |
Direction of Muara Labuh |
Residential and commercial areas |
2 |
Zone 2 |
Kiambang direction |
Residential area Saribu Rumah Gadang |
3 |
Zone 3 |
SRG Area Gate |
Saribu Rumah Gadang residential area |
4 |
Zone 4 |
Directions to Nan Limo Village |
Saribu Rumah Gadang residential area |
5 |
Zone 5 |
Direction Lubuk Jaya |
Saribu Rumah Gadang residential area |
6 |
Zone 6 |
Directions Bariang Kapalo Koto |
Saribu Rumah Gadang residential area |
7 |
Zone 7 |
Direction to Padang Aro |
Residential and commercial areas |
Source : Andalalin 2018 report
To make it easier to identify each traffic zone, below is a picture of the location of each traffic zone that has been determined as explained in Figure 4 below:
Figure 4. Location of traffic zone
5.2 Analysis of internal travel pattern policy design in the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area
Travel patterns were identified to see people's movement patterns in the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area. Community movement patterns in the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area are mostly internal movement patterns related to community cultural activities. The internal movement pattern is shown in the Figure 5.
The movement pattern in number 1 is Rumah Gadang – Surau/mosque – water bank. This movement pattern is related to Balimau's activity, namely, purifying oneself by bathing when entering the month of Ramadan. The movement pattern in number 2 is Rumah Gadang – water bank. This activity is related to building a Rumah Gadang (taking small stones to spread in the yard). The following movement pattern in number 3 is Rumah Gadang - rice fields. This movement pattern is related to work (farming) activities such as going to the fields, cooperation work ceremonies, and sabik (rice harvesting ceremony).
Figure 5. Internal movement pattern in the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area
Figure 6. Installation of external road equipment in the area to reach the parking location
The movement pattern in number 4 is Rumah Gadang – surau/mosque – grave. This movement pattern is related to burial activities. The movement pattern in number 5 is Rumah Gadang – a traditional hall. This movement pattern is related to the activities of Tungku Tigo Sajarangan, namely the Alimulama Deliberative Council, the Ninik Mamak Deliberative Council, and the Bundo Kanduang Deliberative Council. The movement pattern in number 6 is Rumah Gadang – bagalanggang – mosque. This movement pattern is related to the activities of the Aidilfitri and Aidiladha holidays.
The movement pattern in number 7 is Rumah Gadang – surau/mosque. This movement pattern is related to the marriage ceremony. The movement pattern in number 8 is Rumah Gadang – bagalanggang. This movement pattern is related to the baralek gadang activities, namely the procession of pati ambalau, malewakan ka nan rami, basuluah mato hari-bagalanggang mato urang many, also marked by the slaughter of kabau. The movement pattern in number 9 is Rumah Gadang – Bagalanggang – Mosque. This movement pattern is associated with Minangkabau silek/silat activities. The final movement pattern is Rumah Gadang – around the village – Rumah Bako. This movement pattern is related to the activities of the batagak penghulu (the ceremony of appointing the headman). On the first day, the inauguration ceremony was held at the Rumah Gadang, and on the second day, the new prince was paraded to his bako house accompanied by sounds.
To anticipate impacts that occur based on several considerations explained above, detailed (technical) treatment can be proposed, including those related to vehicle circulation, parking arrangements, pedestrian facility design, and road equipment. Installation of road equipment can be classified for the following purposes as follows:
The traffic signs required for this purpose include 12 directions for specific locations and tourist areas, as Figure 6 below explains.
5.3 Analysis of parking management policy design in the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area
Several points of the parking management plan for the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area can be seen in Figure 7 below:
Figure 7. Determining parking locations
Figure 7 above can be described as follows:
Figure 8. Location of pedestrian bridge
5.4 Analysis of tourist circulation policy design in the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area
Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area residents have free access and no restrictions. This is done because residents have lived in the area for generations. Based on the results of the analysis of movement patterns, the daily activities of residents work around the area. Overcrowding occurs when a traditional procession occurs in the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area. The circulation of tourists to the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area is described in Figure 9 as follows:
Figure 9. Tourist circulation scheme
The explanation of the tourist circulation scheme is as follows:
5.5 Analysis of pedestrians in the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area
A safe, comfortable, and humane pedestrian network is an essential component that must be provided to increase the effectiveness of mobility. It is hoped that the availability of a pedestrian network can meet the needs of residents both in terms of quantity and standard of provision. Additionally, integration between pedestrian paths and building layout accessibility between environments and transportation systems still needs to be realized.
Pedestrian network infrastructure and facilities generally facilitate pedestrian movement from one place to another quickly, smoothly, safely, comfortably, and independently, including for pedestrians with physical limitations. The functions of pedestrian infrastructure and facilities are as follows:
In the study area, crossing facilities in the form of zebra crossings are needed. A pedestrian survey was carried out to see the level of use of these facilities, especially those crossing in front of the location.
5.6 Activities and facilities in the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area
The Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area actors consisting of managers, tourists, transportation providers, mini-kiosk traders, homestay managers, and communities in traditional areas carry out their respective activities with the help of facilities, means, or space so that the tourism system can run well. This interaction is shown in the Table 6 below.
Table 6. Description of need in activity the Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area
No. |
Perpetrator |
Activity |
Facilities / Facilities / Space |
1 |
Traveller No stay the night |
Use means core zone transportation, view tower look, follow attractions tourism in Medan Nan Bapaneh, walking and eating and drinking in the traditional area, shopping in a modern area |
Infrastructure/facilities core area transportation, Viewing tower, Medan nan Bapaneh, Rumah gadang, kiosk, gallery |
2 |
Travelers stay the night |
Use means core zone transportation, view tower look, follow attractions tourism in Medan Nan Bapaneh, walking and eating and drinking in the traditional area, shopping in modern areas, staying in homestays |
Infrastructure/facilities core area transportation, Viewing tower, Medan nan Bapaneh, Rumah gadang, kiosk, gallery, homestay |
3 |
Trader stall |
Come, drop out goods, bring goods to stall, sell, rest, go home |
Mini kiosk, warehouse, general facilities, loading dock area |
4 |
Provider transportation |
Bring tool transportation to point arrival, deliver service transportation, rest, and home. |
Point Gather transportation suggestions traditional, facilities general. |
5 |
Manager area tour |
Came, parked vehicle, put goods in the locker, headed each part, rest, go home |
Employee parking, space work, locker, room eat, lane supervision |
6 |
Homestay manager |
Came, parked vehicle, put stuff in a locker, headed each part, rest, go home |
management parking, space work, locker, room eat, lane supervision |
7 |
Traditional Area Community |
Guard comfort, interact with tourists and actors tourist other with Good |
Private house public |
5.7 Policy recommendations
The direction of the Saribu Rumah Gadang (SRG) area management policy is in line with the tourism planning of the Solok Selatan Regency. As part of the sustainable development and development of the SRG tourism area, the SRG tourism area can be directed towards achieving tourism benefits in the form of:
Community involvement in tourism development will better ensure the suitability of development and management programs with local community aspirations and suitability with existing capacities, and it will guarantee community commitment because of a strong sense of ownership. Development that relies on the community in the long term will allow for a high level of continuity. Therefore, in developing the SRG tourism area, a balance is needed between three critical aspects, namely socio-cultural, environmental, and economic.
First, socio-cultural aspects are an understanding of social institutions and the role of humans in change and development. The same is true for the democratic and participation system that provides opportunities to express opinions, choose governments, develop agreements and be aware of differences. Second, environmental aspects include an awareness of natural resources, sensitive physical environments, the impacts of human activities, and decision-making related to the commitment to create social and economic development policies. Third, economic aspects are sensitivity to the limitations and potential of economic growth and its impact on society and the environment, associated with a commitment to evaluate the level of individual and community consumption as a form of concern for the environment and social justice.
The three aspects above are interrelated and are the driving pillars for sustainable tourism development in the SRG area. It is an ideal concept for tourism development where, in its development, tourism must be able to carry out balanced development between economic-environmental-socio-cultural aspects so that the utilization of tourism resources can be carried out sustainably and responsibly without damaging or reducing the value of the resources owned. This is intended so that commercialization efforts (economy) are in line with resource conservation efforts so that they can still be used by future generations.
To realize the benefits and objectives of developing the SRG tourism area, it is necessary to be supported by good governance that involves active participation in a balanced manner between the government, private sector, and the community. Furthermore, based on the context of sustainable development above, tourism activities in the sustainable SRG tourism area can be aligned with the achievement of the mission of the Solok Selatan Regency Government to realize a Solok Selatan tourism destination that is based on culture, environment, creative and innovative, progressive, religious and able to drive sustainable economic development of the community. Achieving this mission can be done by involving community participation and empowerment.
For this reason, a policy recommendation is needed for the management of the Saribu Rumah Gadang tourist area as follows:
The Saribu Rumah Gadang Tourism Area will present two concepts: a modern regional tourism concept located in the core zone and a traditional area in the supporting zone. The modern tourism concept will provide an information centre, mini kiosk, gallery, parking area, and other modern aspects. The traditional concept will provide Rumah Gadang as the main attraction and other supporting attractions such as the history, Ranji, language, and cultural values of each Rumah Gadang. The SRG tourist area can be accessed directly through the main entrance, which is planned to be built through a green open space in Kenagari Pasar Muaro Labuah or the access gate that previously existed at Kenagarian Koto Baru. Suppose vehicle access to the SRG area is directed through a green open space. In that case, it will go through the mayor's office of Muaro Labuah Market and directly enter the modern area, which includes a vehicle parking area, gallery, and mini kiosk that can provide souvenirs for tourists. The SRG parking area is adjacent to the viewing tower, which can be used as a tourist attraction in the SRG area to observe the SRG area from a certain height.
The planning of the development and development of the SRG tourism area is one part of the development of the Strategic Area, including the strategy of developing the strategic location as a cultural heritage area supported by many traditional houses. Then, to encourage the development and optimization of the tourism area in Solok Selatan Regency, the planning of the development and development of the SRG tourism area is carried out by considering several things as follows:
Governance of the WRS area must involve the active participation of people who live, do activities, and mingle in the WRS area, tourism awareness groups (Pokdarwis), the private sector, which can be represented by tourism associations, and the central, regional and Nagari governments which are very determining factors in encouraging and moving tourism in the SRG area to become a leading tourist destination, thereby providing more excellent benefits both in terms of history, culture and economics.
The Research Team appreciates and is most grateful to the Research Center for Policy, Governance, Development & Empowerment Universitas Negeri Padang for conducting this research.
[1] Suwena, I.K., Widyatmaja, I.G.N. (2017). Pengetahuan Dasar Ilmu Pariwisata. Pustaka Larasan.
[2] Butler, R.W. (2020). Sustainable tourism: A state-of-the-art review. Tourism Geographies, 1(1): 7-25. https://doi.org/10.1080/14616689908721291
[3] Weaver, D. (2007). Sustainable Tourism. Routledge.
[4] UNWTO. (2018). UN Tourism Highlights: 2018 Edition. https://www.e-unwto.org/doi/book/10.18111/9789284419876, accessed on Jul. 31, 2019.
[5] Lozano-Oyola, M., Blancas, F.J., Gonzalez, M., Caballero, R. (2019). Sustainable tourism tags to reward destination management. Journal of Environmental Management, 250: 109458. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2019.109458
[6] Fatimah, S., Naldi, J. (2019). Implementation of the penta-helix approach model against development sustainable tourism. International Journal of Tourism, Heritage and Recreation Sport, 1(2): 19-29.
[7] Fatimah, S., Fitriani, E., Retnaningtyas, S., Syafrina, Y., Basri, E., Alhadi, Z., Rivauzi, A., Patra, H. (2023). Potential application of history and culture-based integrated tourism model in Batu Patah Payo, West Sumatra. International Journal of Sustainable Development and Planning, 18,(12): 3801-3809. https://doi.org/10.18280/ijsdp.181212
[8] Bremner, H., Wikitera, K.A. (2016). Using history for tourism or using tourism for history? Examples from Aotearoa/New Zealand. Journal of Tourism History, 8(3): 260-274. https://doi.org/10.1080/1755182X.2017.1279233
[9] Rizkianto, N., Topowijono, T. (2018). Penerapan konsepcommunity based tourism dalam pengelolaan daya tarikwisata berkelanjutan (Studi pada desa wisata bangun,kecamatan munjungan, kabupaten trenggalek). JurnalAdministrasi Bisnis, 58(1): 20-26.
[10] .Alhadi, Z., Muchtar, B., Evanita, S. (2023). Developing a community-based tourism model for sustainable tourism in the mandeh area, West Sumatra Province, Indonesia. International Journal of Sustainable Development & Planning, 18(11): 3491-3503. https://doi.org/10.18280/ijsdp.181114
[11] Rodríguez, J.R.O., Parra-López, E., Yanes-Estévez, V. (2008). The sustainability of island destinations: Tourism area life cycle and teleological perspectives. The case of Tenerife. Tourism Management, 29(1): 53-65. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tourman.2007.04.007
[12] Vila, M., Costa, G., Rovira, X. (2010). The creation and use of scorecards in tourism planning: A Spanish example. Tourism Management, 31(2): 232-239. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tourman.2009.02.015
[13] Zhang, X. (2012). Research on the development strategies of rural tourism in Suzhou based on SWOT analysis. Energy Procedia, 16: 1295-1299. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.egypro.2012.01.207
[14] Budeanu, A., Miller, G., Moscardo, G., Ooi, C.S. (2016). Sustainable tourism, progress, challenges and opportunities: An introduction. Journal of Cleaner Production, 111: 285-294. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2015.10.027
[15] Lozano-Oyola, M., Blancas, F.J., Gonzalez, M., Caballero, R. (2019). Sustainable tourism tags to reward destination management. Journal of Environmental Management, 250: 109458. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2019.109458
[16] Saputra, A., Ali, K. (2020). Analisis kebijakan pariwisata terhadap pengelolaan objek wisata di kabupaten samosir. Warta Dharmawangsa, 14(4): 564-584. https://doi.org/10.46576/wdw.v14i4.889
[17] Guo, Y., Jiang, J., Li, S. (2019). A sustainable tourism policy research review. Sustainability, 11(11): 3187. https://doi.org/10.3390/su11113187
[18] Yenti, N.S., Yusran, R., Alhadi, Z., Fajri, H. (2024). Evaluasi pengelolaan kebijakan kepariwisataan, objek wisata danau diatas, kecamatan lembah gumanti kabupaten solok. Jurnal Administrasi Pemerintahan Desa, 5(1). https://sdoi.org/10.47134/villages.v5i1.71
[19] Vetrova, E.A., Kabanova, E.E.E., Nakhratova, E.E., Baynova, M.S., Evstratova, T.A. (2018). Project management in the sphere of tourism (using the example of Taganrog). Academy of Strategic Management Journal, 17(3): 1-9.
[20] Yomi, W.G., Adnan, M.F., Alhadi, Z. (2019). Development of Nagari Tuo Pariangan tourism object by the youth and sports tourism office of Tanah Datar regency. JPSI (Journal of Public Sector Innovations), 3(1): 6-11. https://doi.org/10.26740/jpsi.v3n1.p6-11
[21] Zefnihan, Muchtar, B., Evanita, S., Aimon, H., Azhar, Z., Alhadi, Z. (2021). Mapping analysis of potential tourism products in mandeh integrated tourism region–Indonesia. Academy of Strategic Management Journal, 20: 1-6.
[22] Spenceley, A., Snyman, S., Eagles, P.F. (2019). A decision framework on the choice of management models for park and protected area tourism services. Journal of Outdoor Recreation and Tourism, 26: 72-80. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jort.2019.03.004
[23] Fitriani, M.F., Yusran, R., Maani, K.D., Alhadi, Z. (2023). Development governance policy the kawasan Saribu rumah gadang (SRG) in Solok Selatan Regency. Science and Environmental Journal for Postgraduate, 5(2): 133-137. https://doi.org/10.24036/senjop.v5i2.193
[24] Su’udi, A., Suwandono, D. (2015). Perencanaan konsep pengelolaan dan pembiayaan pembangunan kawasan wisata hutan mangrove desa bedono, kecamatan sayung, kabupaten demak. Ruang, 1(2): 41-50. https://doi.org/10.14710/ruang.1.2.51-60
[25] Inskeep, E. (1991). Tourism Planning: An Integrated and Sustainable Development Approach. John Wiley & Sons.
[26] Paturusi, S.A. (2008). Perencanaan Kawasan Pariwisata. Denpasar: Universitas Udayana.
[27] Yoeti, O.A. (2002). Perencanaan Strategis pemasaran Daerah Tujuan Wisata. Jakarta: Pradnya Paramita.
[28] UNWTO. (2004). Indicators of Sustainable Development for Tourism Destinations A Guidebook (English Version). UNWTO, Madrid. https://doi.org/10.18111/9789284407262
[29] Lukoseviciute, G., Panagopoulos, T. (2021). Management priorities from tourists' perspectives and beach quality assessment as tools to support sustainable coastal tourism. Ocean & Coastal Management, 208: 105646. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ocecoaman.2021.105646
[30] MacNeill, T., Wozniak, D. (2018). The economic, social, and environmental impacts of cruise tourism. Tourism Management, 66: 387-404. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tourman.2017.11.002
[31] Gladstone, W., Curley, B., Shokri, M.R. (2013). Environmental impacts of tourism in the Gulf and the Red Sea. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 72(2): 375-388. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpolbul.2012.09.017
[32] Tang, Z. (2015). An integrated approach to evaluating the coupling coordination between tourism and the environment. Tourism Management, 46: 11-19. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tourman.2014.06.001
[33] Zhong, L., Deng, J., Song, Z., Ding, P. (2011). Research on environmental impacts of tourism in China: Progress and prospect. Journal of Environmental Management, 92(11): 2972-2983. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2011.07.011
[34] Kurniawan, F., Adrianto, L., Bengen, D.G., Prasetyo, L.B. (2019). The social-ecological status of small islands: An evaluation of island tourism destination management in Indonesia. Tourism Management Perspectives, 31: 136-144. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tmp.2019.04.004
[35] Pan, S.Y., Gao, M., Kim, H., Shah, K.J., Pei, S.L., Chiang, P.C. (2018). Advances and challenges in sustainable tourism toward a green economy. Science of the Total Environment, 635: 452-469. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2018.04.134